I am not sure if it looks like a turkey but when you make crafts for kids that is not as important as the fine motor skills involved and having fun.
I cut the turkey's body out of a detergent bottle. The head and flabby neck thing are cut from the top of a spring water bottle. It fit inside the handle opening nicely.
Press down on paper to use as a stencil. Kids can color inside the cut out shapes and around the border to make a basic turkey shape and then add details and colors. Some kids will prefer free form coloring but others might be encouraged by having a model to work from.
Children can also wrap yarn around the openings to decorate.